Saturday, November 21, 2026

I Suffered Fraud so You Don't Have to: Hints to Tell if Someone Is an ACX Scammer

 If you've been following me, you know a few weeks ago, I came across a video where an ACX voice actor is telling everyone not to solely use Royalty Share for any project. I objected to this at the time, but I was then presented with an offer that I could not turn down--especially when I was low on sleep since I was working 13-hour days at the theater.

When I got the idea to do my Upsilon Andromedae mashups, I wanted to do both romance and mystery books. The Waylaid Count was the first of my mysteries. I was also doing a lot of Reader's Favorite reviews at the time, and the first ones, I signed with my full name, making it easy for authors I gave lower reviews to find me. I have a very public profile so I can connect with my own audience. Although I thought a Nancy-Drew-style mashup mystery would be cool, and I really liked this book, I got a 1-star review with no feedback. 😞These books are serials, so I posted the first half as installments on one of my other blogs dedicated to them. Then, I put some of them in for reviews, and although the reviews weren't necessarily negative, they were in the 3-4 star range instead of 4+. So, I decided to stop the blog rework both of the series, and as part of that rework, I smoothed out some of the older language. I am submitting the Waylaid Count to Review Group on Goodreads and seeing how the reviews go now. As part of this reboot, I would like a narrated version, and since it is a first-person Nancy-Drew-style, a young, American female voice would be ideal, in my opinion. 

Unlike the other book I posted for Royalty Share, I decided to send this to specific actresses. The first one ignored my request, which I expected. (I have now realized that I am just going to have to submit this to anyone interested and see who applies, but I will do it after I get more reviews.) 

1. The first warning bell: You are asked to move off platform to communicate.

The second person I specifically sent the request to, "Mia Carter," responded quickly, to my surprise, and poured out the praise. Then, in the on ACX messaging system, she immediately gave me her email and requested that I send a PDF of the book to her so she could read it to see if we were a good fit. She also suggested taking part in marketing the book since "both of us would be invested in it." 

I don't know why this is such a typical scammer thing to move you off platform to a private e-mail setting. Do most people delete their e-mails once they are sent? I keep copies both ways, and you should too--preferably in a folder marked "business" or something like that. It is also always easier to report communication if you do it through an on-site messaging system--as long as you are only reporting the issues to that platform.

2. The second warning bell: Praise of your book is followed by a request for money outside of the contract you offered.

I sent her a copy of my book, which gave her my e-mail, so all further communication occurred that way. Her next e-mail contained more praise. It also gave a detailed outline of all the marketing things she was going to do, for example, create a 3D cover (to which I was like, big deal), create modules for A+ Content (which I checked with Google and all this stuff was a big deal in the end), give me 50 codes for my book so I could give it away for free (and believe me, I was raising an eyebrow at this because I wondered if she was going to pay for them--it turns out we both get 50 codes when a Royalty Share contract is used and Audible is listed as the exclusive distributor), and create a chapter teaser for a prequel that could be given away for free if people sign up to my newsletter. The cost: $300 up front. Alternately, she said she would do a per-hour rate for $300 up front and $300 afterward. Neither of these was what I had offered.

Now, I rolled my eyes at the praise, but it makes perfect sense. She sees this author who has gotten one 1-star review for her book and who is trying to now do an audiobook and knows that praise is the best way to hook her. (I am not happy about the 1-star, but that is primarily because I want these books to succeed and not leaving feedback doesn't help me fix what is wrong. I don't need someone to tell me garbage is good to stroke my ego.) However, she mentioned one specific incident in the book that my sleep-deprived brain thought was unique--so she convinced me she had read at least the first chapter despite having a summary that sounded AI-written--although I was still suspicious. Every step of the way, I had inner conflicts because what she said made sense, and I inherently want to believe people are decent. If she truly liked the book, she would want to promote it to help herself make more money. 

However, I had not offered to pay anything-only a Royalty Share. Still, $300 was a good price for all the promotional material she was offering on the side. And, yes, I heard the "If it sounds too good to be true, then it probably is" cliché echoing repeatedly in my head. The problem is that if it increased sales, she would be making a lot more money off of it, too. So the war in my head continued.

At this point, I would have normally cut off communication, blocked her, and reported her as spam, but (1) The voice actor in the YouTube video's comments were ringing in the back of my head about how voice actors should always get money as part of their contract; and (2) I knew the promotional package she was offering would help me to promote my other books because I could repeat the process for them, (3) I checked the platform she wanted to use to exchange money (Gumroad) and it was ligitimate so I knew I could get my money back and my credit card information was protected (I only found out later when reporting the issue that Gumroad does not allow "service" transactions, which was what she was primarily offering by offering me marketing consultation); and (4) I planned to use a credit card, which offers its own protection--as long as someone can't steal your numbers. 

3. The third warning bell: She has no samples of her promotional work.

When I asked for samples of some of the other books she had promoted, she said she could not show me anything because of NDAs. 

So, I understand NDAs, but had I been thinking: she had not volunteered to sign one with me, which if that was her standard, it seems she would have done so. Was I the first person to have not requested one? Further, most of the things she was saying she did were A+ content modules, which she could have easily shown me by linking to one that was published. Finally, anyone who has been doing things like this for a while would normally have samples of previous work to show new clients, even if they are samples just made to be samples.

4. The fourth warning bell: The contract you offered is allowed to expire without being accepted.

In the process of deciding the above, I wanted to make sure she knew she would not be writing the "free" giveaway chapter for my Upsilon Andromedae series. I would write it, and she could comment on it--which she agreed to. In addition, a clear outline of dates was set as to when things would be due, but this was only set in e-mails, (and presumably, she only did it to seem more official after my question about when I would first need to help her since I was working so much.) Then, the contract I had offered her expired on ACX. I did not (and still do not) know if someone can still accept an expired contract, but I feel like I would have had to send it to her again. She, however, was ahead of the game on this one and let me know that she wanted to get the promotional material dealt with first and then she would sign the contract.

Okay, so I am thankful she set a list of things with dates. I still would have been trying to contact her after a few weeks, but a list of dates gives you evidence that you were supposed to receive things at a certain time. The ACX contract had this in it, but I might not have thought about putting anything in the e-mails to her if she hadn't done that for me, thankfully. To protect yourself (and this goes both ways for freelancer/voice actor and employer/rights holder), always get dates in writing for your work, and if that changes after the contract has been created, write everything down and agree to the changes. 

ACX does not have marketing consultation as part of its contracts. Anything paid for marketing (as opposed to a per-hour rate, which is what she would have had to charge if we had changed the Royalty Share contract I offered to a Royalty Plus contract for the ~$300) would have been considered for narrating the book, and none of the marketing would have been included under the terms of that contract. We had, however, already laid out extremely specific items in the e-mails. Again, make sure if you are doing something like this, that you get everything spelled out: who is doing what when.

A Royalty Share Plus contract should have been okay for her if she were honestly involved, because the promotional items were supposed to help both of us. Alternately, since I had already agreed to pay her for the additional amount, as soon as I did she should have been okay with signing a contract--instead of telling me she would only sign it after she delivered the things she promised. 

However, if she had said she wanted a Royalty Share Plus contract for that price, I might have balked and seen it as her trying to manipulate me into paying a reduced Per-hour fee because that is really what it would have been. I also do not know what would have happened if I accepted her ~$600 Per-Hour contract instead--would she have allowed me to change and reoffer the contract? Or would she have said that she would sign the contract as soon as we got the first payment out of the way to avoid that legality? I suspect that she would have tried to keep it off ACX. 

Looking back, I also wonder what she would have done if I had contacted her through their message system about our e-mails. Whatever "might" have happened, once the contract expired, I should have told her I was not paying until it was accepted. That might not have gotten me the promotional deal, but it would have given me more of a complaint on the ACX platform if she didn't finish the narration. 

5. The fifth warning bell: Radio silence.

Everything in our e-mails was about collaboration. These were frequent, even though I told her I was working 13-hour days at the theater (which I was). Then she got paid, and I didn't hear anything except her confirmation of receipt. Contrast this with the person I hired through Royalty Share only in a future post (that is still in process, and I want to finish the process before posting about it). 

The confirmation of receipt did several things: (1) it kept me from contacting Gumroad to see if she had received the funds. (2) It prevented me from looking closely at the receipt I got from Gumroad, which said I had paid "Audible Edge AI" (AI narration will get rejected if detected by ACX, by the way) and gave an entirely different e-mail address. (3) It reassured me she was still there even after getting paid, so I did not immediately cancel my payment. 

When I did open the receipt, I realized saw that she had not sent anything in the request for payment, but a document outlining our agreement (which seems to have been sent to trick Gumroad into believing the money was for that document). Gumroad even sent me a request to review her as if the job were done. 

At almost the two-week point, I sent her an e-mail. I waited three days, and then started digging. Here I learned that I needed to send a second e-mail telling her to refund my money within 48 hours of it because she had missed two milestones (and I did). I sent this one to the e-mail address on the receipt. This is important for legal reasons. It shows you were trying to get your money back. I prepared to get excuses/apologies and being begged to let her do the job without refunding my money. If she had sent that, I would have briefly explained she had missed two milestones and our agreement was void because of her failure. This may seem harsh, but there is no reason she could not have contacted me to tell me she was going to be late or even give me partially complete work so I had proof she was working on something. Once you ask for a refund, you can't allow any crocodile tears to sway you to accept anything but a full refund. In my case, she did not contact me during this time.  

6. The sixth warning bell, which should have been my first: Lies on her profile.

This was 100% me being stupid. I had glanced at her ACX profile, but I had already determined profile information to be garbage because the voice actors put it in themselves and there is no third-party feedback. I did do a quick online search for a "corporate trainer" named Mia Carter in Ohio, but when I couldn't find anyone, I didn't think much of it. When she went silent, though, I went back to her profile. It claimed she had done the narration for two books from big name books/publishers: "Atomic Habits" (Penguin), "Never Split the Difference" (HarperBusiness). Since I was just checking her out as a voice actor and had dismissed her profile as unhelpful, I primarily listened to her samples. When I went back, though, and decided to fact-check her (primarily because those are big-name publishers, so the information was easy to find) neither of those books were narrated by "Mia Carter"--in fact, men narrate both of them. The award she supposedly got: AudioFile Best Business Narrator 2023, is similar to a real award, but non-existent.

No comments:

Post a Comment